Neutral News
INDIA · 17 Nov 2026 · 01:31 GMT ·3 min read

RBI and YES Bank Challenge Supreme Court Ruling on ₹8,415 Crore AT-1 Bond Write-Off

The Reserve Bank of India and YES Bank filed separate Supreme Court review petitions challenging an October 15, 2026, judgment.

NEUTRALITY 88 · BALANCED· 7 sources
Neutrality score measures balance across loaded language, source diversity, opinion-vs-fact framing, and context omissions.
70-100 BALANCED · 40-69 MIXED · 0-39 LEANING.

EquityPandit

The Reserve Bank of India and YES Bank filed separate Supreme Court review petitions challenging an October 15, 2026, judgment. This ruling set aside the write-off of ₹8,415 crore (84.15 billion rupees) in Additional Tier-1 (AT-1) bonds. The RBI argues the decision creates uncertainty for future bank resolutions and ignores Basel III loss-absorption mechanisms. YES Bank warns that restoring these bonds could reduce its core capital ratio by 2.4 to 2.5 percentage points. Axis Trustee Services, representing bondholders, filed a contempt petition against the lender.

Context

YES Bank faced severe financial stress in March 2020, leading the Reserve Bank of India to impose a moratorium on March 5, 2020, and supersede the bank's board. The administrator subsequently wrote down the entire ₹8,415 crore worth of AT-1 bonds on March 14, 2020. This action occurred despite the final reconstruction scheme, submitted to the Union government, omitting the specific provision to write down these instruments.

Axis Trustee Services challenged the write-down in the Bombay High Court in May 2020. The Supreme Court upheld this decision on October 15, 2026, dismissing the appeals.

The central bank contends the ruling did not distinguish between pre-specified triggers and the point of non-viability (PONV) trigger under the Basel III framework.

The central bank seeks to pause the ruling's effect pending the disposal of its plea.

The court found that the power to write down the instruments could not be exercised after the reconstruction scheme had already come into force.

The Supreme Court's October 15, 2026, ruling mandated that yearly coupons remain payable under the original bond terms. This requirement applies whatever happens in the appeals.

Supportive perspectives

  1. The Reserve Bank of India (RBI) warns that restoring written-down bonds could dilute capital injected into YES Bank during its 2020 reconstruction. The regulator says this move undermines the loss-absorbing role of Additional Tier-1 (AT-1) instruments across the banking sector.

  2. The RBI argues that the Supreme Court's October 15, 2026, judgment failed to adequately consider the Basel III Master Circular provisions governing the loss-absorption mechanism of AT-1 bonds. The regulator contends the court did not sufficiently distinguish between pre-specified triggers and the point of non-viability trigger under the Basel III framework.

  3. The Reserve Bank of India (RBI) requested an open-court hearing and a stay on the October 15, 2026, judgment. The bank asks the court to reconsider the ruling that set aside the 84.15 billion rupee (8,415 crore) write-off while the legal challenge remains pending.

  4. YES Bank filed a review petition under Article 137 of the Constitution on November 13, 2026. The bank informed stock exchanges that it is seeking reconsideration of the October 15, 2026, verdict.

Critical perspectives

  1. Axis Trustee Services filed a contempt petition against YES Bank in the Supreme Court. The firm acts on behalf of bondholders. The trustee alleges the bank failed to provide a roadmap for restoring AT-1 bonds. This failure violates a previous court order.

  2. YES Bank stated that restoring the bonds could reduce its core capital ratio by approximately 2.4 to 2.5 percentage points, based on June 2026 figures.

  3. The Supreme Court interpreted the removal of the AT-1 write-off clause from the final reconstruction scheme as a deliberate decision by the government not to write down the bonds. This interpretation directly contradicts the RBI's contention that the clause's deletion was not a conscious decision to shield bondholders. Instead, the RBI maintained that AT-1 bonds are contractually governed by its Basel III Master Circular, which requires these instruments to absorb losses before a bank is reconstructed, regardless of whether a specific write-off clause appeared in the final government notification.

  4. In January 2023, the Bombay High Court quashed the write-down. The court ruled that the administrator lacked the authority to act once the reconstruction scheme took effect. Bondholders seeking restoration continue to cite this precedent as a point of contention.

Sources verified by Neutral

This story is built from the reporting below. Tap a source to read the original.

Found this perspective valuable?

Get the full picture on the Neutral News app

Both sides of every story on one page, with a neutrality score on top. Follow stories as they unfold. On Android and iPhone.

Get it on Google PlayDownload on the App Store
Neutral NewsWorld
WORLD
82
BALANCED
Neutrality score
Supportive
Critical
Tap to get the app ›